Bhopal and Sambhavna
So it is Saturday night here, very late, and I'm the only one awake. Don't feel like sleeping quite yet and need to catch up here. I have way too much to say.
I guess I should start by describing in some detail where, exactly, I am. The address here is actually another perfect example of how addresses are in India:
Sambhavna Trust Clinic
Bafna Colony
Berasia Road
Bhopal 462 001
Madhya Pradesh, India
"Bafna Colony" is just the name of this general neighborhood -- it is slightly more descriptive in its precision than it would be to specify the neighborhood "Dumbo" on a letter to Brooklyn. Berasia Road is the nearest big road -- the only thing around here that would even be considered a real street in a place like New York. It is few minutes' walk from here. And Bhopal is the city, of course. So to get here you do as I did -- get to Berasia Road upon arrival in Bhopal and go down it until you are alongside Bafna Colony, and then turn into it. You are now in a dense tangle of dusty, semi-paved "streets" that I would be more inclined to call "footpaths" or something like that. Most of them are wide enough for just one small car (although you will rarely see an actual car here) but many are not. Most people around here are on foot, and the ones who aren't are on motorcycles or vespa-style things. Autorickshaws come in here with a little prodding (one refused the other night and we just had to walk the rest of the way). In this immediate area most of the buildings are actually solid constructions made of brick and concrete. It varies a lot, though -- many of the homes are made of scraps of wood, sheet metal, plastic tarps, and other things. The ones that are really made of brick are often incomplete -- the have no roof, for instance, or are missing a few walls. It's hard to tell whether they were never finished being built or if they used to be complete and fell apart. I will try to get some photos posted here once I get my internet access sorted out.
The clinic building is new -- it opened just this past April. It is a beautiful place -- not just relative to its surroundings, but in its own right. Two floors, all bricks, concrete and wood. All the walls are brick and the ceilings wood. Whether from the architecture, the occupants, or both, the whole place has a very warm and human feel to it -- it feels like a safe place. The only people who actually live here are volunteers like me. Right now there are only two others, Matthias from Zurich, Switzerland, and Maude from Providence, Rhode Island. Matthias is an environmental science student and is one of the sweetest guys I have ever met in my life. Maude chooses the title of "artist" to best describe herself and she is here doing photography and archival work. She, too, is very cool. She used to live in NYC in the 60's, working as a photojournalist.
We all sleep on the second floor. Matthias and I sleep in a room that roughly the size of my old apartment in New York, but which has six beds in it (two bunk beds and two others), each fitted with mosquito nets. Up on the second floor with us is also a kitchen, a laundry area, the library and research rooms, and huge, open-sky terrace areas.
The first floor is a much busier place. Every morning it is filled with people (roughly 100), mostly women and children, who are here for the many services the clinic provides. I am told that these days most of the people coming here are victims of the poisoned drinking water and about a quarter to a third are victims directly of the gas that night 21 years ago. Some people are visibly affected. I don't know enough about the health effects to write intelligently about it right now, but the methyl isocyanate gas did something awful to people's eyes. That is just one of many, many things the gas did, but it's one effect that is very visible. There have also been effects on children born here after 1984. Very heavy, a lot to take in, a lot to feel and think about.
The day before yesterday I went over near the Union Carbide factory for the first time. It's about a five-minute walk from here. The actual MIC tank that leaked and the surrounding equipment is set back a few hundred feet from a concrete wall that runs along what everyone still calls Union Carbide Road. The people that live around there live in much humbler conditions even than those near Sambhavna, only a few blocks away. I passed a water pump on Union Carbide Road that was painted red to warn locals that the water was poison, but it has since been taken out of service, anyway. Now, the local government comes regularly to fill a few large, cylindrical, plastic tanks with better water for people to drink. The tanks are a little taller than I am and about 6 feet wide. The wall of the Union Carbide property is mostly covered with painted political messages against Union Carbide and Dow, in both English and Hindi. Our presence there attracted a huge crowd of children and a few adults, all very friendly. One man came out and waded through the knot of children encircling us and at first it seemed like he might be angry -- his face seemed to ask what we were doing there and he was pointing over to the Union Carbide site -- but I shook his hand and said a few broken words of explanation and he warmed up immediately. I was worried because someone had said something just a few minutes before about some Westerners getting rocks thrown at them on that street. The appearance and conditions over there right by the old pesticide plant are much worse than they are around the clinic. It looks to be something between a permanent neighborhood and a campsite. Much fewer structures are made of things like concrete and brick and many more are made of found materials. Everything is jammed together, dense and thick, very crowded. I will try to post a photo at some point. It looks much like Miami would look if no one got any insurance money for many years after a hurricane destroyed absolutely everything, but with everyone still living there in the same spot. It's hard to describe.
I have a hard time taking photos of a lot of things here -- often the snapshots that would be of greatest interest to you all back home. I don't feel comfortable with going to places like Union Carbide road, for instance, and displaying my shock at the appearance of someone's home by walking up and snapping photos. This has been a problem for me all over India. Everything around me the whole time I've been here has been incredible in a wide variety of ways. I've only felt comfortable with taking photos of a few things, though.
In general, foreigners attract a lot of attention here, even just walking outside. Except for my companions here at Sambhavna, I have not seen a single Westerner here in Bhopal or in Madhya Pradesh. I don't really expect to see any, either. I don't think anyone comes here to visit. So people really look at us. Adults just look, but the children speak right up as soon as they see me. Most commonly they say "hello!" or "hello! how are you?!" very enthusiastically and in an almost inquiring way, and they are very pleased if I bounce back with a "hello, I'm fine, thank you!" It's pretty much the only English they know and I think they just get a big kick out of using it and getting a response. The way children, and even some adults here in India look at me has been very intense. Not in a bad way. Very refreshing, actually, after so many years in 'let's-all-pretend-we-we're-not-standing-here-together-in-this-subway/elevator/cafe' New York. People here really look at you, right into your eyes. That morning I had breakfast with the hotel owner in Jaipur I kept looking down at my plate and to the side and every time I'd glance back up his eyes were locked into mine, gazing right to the very back of them. Looking at him felt like looking into the sun. I found that a lot here. It is a good thing.
At night it's just the three of us here along with a couple of guards that watch the entrance to the clinic. We sit outside on the terrace to eat or drink tea. There are many moments when I feel like we are on a space station together. Or maybe like we are at one of those Antarctic laboratory stations. Of course we are surrounded by people here, but it's quite an alien panorama, especially if you've just arrived. Also, there only a couple of people here who speak fluent English -- Sathyu and Rachna. There are then a few others who speak some English. And that's it. My Hindi is still way too limited to really talk with people. I'm working on it, though. Very soon I might be the only foreigner here, at least for a while. Matthias is leaving in two weeks and Maude might leave even before then. Sathyu and Rachna are great company, too, but they are extremely busy and don't do much hanging out upstairs. This very charismatic 13-year-old boy named Zuber who lives nearby has latched onto me and comes everyday and stands on the other side of the clinic's fence and calls out my name. He really wants to hang out and be friends, but I badly need to learn more Hindi.
I took this week's dose of mefloquine this morning and I'm feeling a little nauseated from it. I'm really glad, though, that I came here already on it instead of assuming there wouldn't be enough mosquitos in January to justify the side effects. There actually aren't that many mosquitos most of the time, but in the evening they are everywhere and very aggressive. Matthias got sick again last night with malarial symptoms and he is worried that the chloroquine & primaquine combo isn't working, but it is still too early to tell. I'm the only one around here taking mefloquine because people want to avoid the side effects. The malaria treatment involves taking up to six times the normal dosage of chloroquine, though, and the side effects from that aren't pleasant, either. And neither is the malaria, of course.
I did end up bringing my ipod to India, with the excuse that it contained three volumes of Hindi lessons on it. Hanna had told me last year that when she came to Bhopal she couldn't listen to any of the music she brought because it just made no sense over there. This hasn't been exactly the case for me. Hipsters and irony don't make any sense here. That makes dead weight out of roughly half my ipod. The album I've been listening to most is U2's *All That You Can't Leave Behind*. It's funny because I never listened to any U2 at all back in NYC -- it was always a little too wholesome for me back there. Here I like it a lot. The music is earnest and unpretentious to my ears, and throws frequent bones to the more serious problems of the world. Maybe I just don't know anything about Bono and that's fine, really. I don't want to know. It's a little life raft for me right now. I badly need some rock and roll, and with as little b.s. as possible.
There is almost constant music coming from the area surrounding the clinic. I arrived here halfway through a nearby wedding celebration that lasted for three days. They had a very loud sound system and played a loop of mostly Hindi songs until past midnight and starting back up at around sunrise. Non-stop. And a live hand drummer, too. Some of the music they played was Western and was quite surreally ill-fitted to our surroundings. When we walked over there, for instance, they cranked up this house beat song "Shake Your Booty." All the kids went wild jumping up and down ecstatically and freeze dancing into these fantastic poses. This in a place where there are almost as many goats and cows walking around as there are people. And I am 100% sure that no one around here knows what "shake your booty" means.
Then there is the Muslim prayer cantor, too. The one closest to here is a little off key, I think. I liked the one by my hotel in Jaipur, better, actually. I didn't hear any in Udaipur. There are also explosions all the time, sometimes one every 30 seconds, like right now as I type this. They are the same "fireworks" I heard in Udaipur. I have to put "fireworks" in quotes because they are just so totally bombs. They sound the way it sounds when a transformer on an electrical pole blows up. It's a deep, full-bodied boom that I can feel in my chest if it's not too far away.
Ok, I should stop now and try to get some sleep. Lots to do tomorrow. There is so much more to write about, but I'll have to save it for later. For now, though, I should say that I feel very good. It has been two weeks since I arrived in India. In those two weeks I have learned that I am not nearly as tough as I thought I was in a lot of ways, but I have also amazed myself -- watched myself, really, almost from above, with compassionate fascination. Coming to India and to Bhopal, especially, has been a very good thing for me. I haven't been so happy in a very long time. More later,
MM
I guess I should start by describing in some detail where, exactly, I am. The address here is actually another perfect example of how addresses are in India:
Sambhavna Trust Clinic
Bafna Colony
Berasia Road
Bhopal 462 001
Madhya Pradesh, India
"Bafna Colony" is just the name of this general neighborhood -- it is slightly more descriptive in its precision than it would be to specify the neighborhood "Dumbo" on a letter to Brooklyn. Berasia Road is the nearest big road -- the only thing around here that would even be considered a real street in a place like New York. It is few minutes' walk from here. And Bhopal is the city, of course. So to get here you do as I did -- get to Berasia Road upon arrival in Bhopal and go down it until you are alongside Bafna Colony, and then turn into it. You are now in a dense tangle of dusty, semi-paved "streets" that I would be more inclined to call "footpaths" or something like that. Most of them are wide enough for just one small car (although you will rarely see an actual car here) but many are not. Most people around here are on foot, and the ones who aren't are on motorcycles or vespa-style things. Autorickshaws come in here with a little prodding (one refused the other night and we just had to walk the rest of the way). In this immediate area most of the buildings are actually solid constructions made of brick and concrete. It varies a lot, though -- many of the homes are made of scraps of wood, sheet metal, plastic tarps, and other things. The ones that are really made of brick are often incomplete -- the have no roof, for instance, or are missing a few walls. It's hard to tell whether they were never finished being built or if they used to be complete and fell apart. I will try to get some photos posted here once I get my internet access sorted out.
The clinic building is new -- it opened just this past April. It is a beautiful place -- not just relative to its surroundings, but in its own right. Two floors, all bricks, concrete and wood. All the walls are brick and the ceilings wood. Whether from the architecture, the occupants, or both, the whole place has a very warm and human feel to it -- it feels like a safe place. The only people who actually live here are volunteers like me. Right now there are only two others, Matthias from Zurich, Switzerland, and Maude from Providence, Rhode Island. Matthias is an environmental science student and is one of the sweetest guys I have ever met in my life. Maude chooses the title of "artist" to best describe herself and she is here doing photography and archival work. She, too, is very cool. She used to live in NYC in the 60's, working as a photojournalist.
We all sleep on the second floor. Matthias and I sleep in a room that roughly the size of my old apartment in New York, but which has six beds in it (two bunk beds and two others), each fitted with mosquito nets. Up on the second floor with us is also a kitchen, a laundry area, the library and research rooms, and huge, open-sky terrace areas.
The first floor is a much busier place. Every morning it is filled with people (roughly 100), mostly women and children, who are here for the many services the clinic provides. I am told that these days most of the people coming here are victims of the poisoned drinking water and about a quarter to a third are victims directly of the gas that night 21 years ago. Some people are visibly affected. I don't know enough about the health effects to write intelligently about it right now, but the methyl isocyanate gas did something awful to people's eyes. That is just one of many, many things the gas did, but it's one effect that is very visible. There have also been effects on children born here after 1984. Very heavy, a lot to take in, a lot to feel and think about.
The day before yesterday I went over near the Union Carbide factory for the first time. It's about a five-minute walk from here. The actual MIC tank that leaked and the surrounding equipment is set back a few hundred feet from a concrete wall that runs along what everyone still calls Union Carbide Road. The people that live around there live in much humbler conditions even than those near Sambhavna, only a few blocks away. I passed a water pump on Union Carbide Road that was painted red to warn locals that the water was poison, but it has since been taken out of service, anyway. Now, the local government comes regularly to fill a few large, cylindrical, plastic tanks with better water for people to drink. The tanks are a little taller than I am and about 6 feet wide. The wall of the Union Carbide property is mostly covered with painted political messages against Union Carbide and Dow, in both English and Hindi. Our presence there attracted a huge crowd of children and a few adults, all very friendly. One man came out and waded through the knot of children encircling us and at first it seemed like he might be angry -- his face seemed to ask what we were doing there and he was pointing over to the Union Carbide site -- but I shook his hand and said a few broken words of explanation and he warmed up immediately. I was worried because someone had said something just a few minutes before about some Westerners getting rocks thrown at them on that street. The appearance and conditions over there right by the old pesticide plant are much worse than they are around the clinic. It looks to be something between a permanent neighborhood and a campsite. Much fewer structures are made of things like concrete and brick and many more are made of found materials. Everything is jammed together, dense and thick, very crowded. I will try to post a photo at some point. It looks much like Miami would look if no one got any insurance money for many years after a hurricane destroyed absolutely everything, but with everyone still living there in the same spot. It's hard to describe.
I have a hard time taking photos of a lot of things here -- often the snapshots that would be of greatest interest to you all back home. I don't feel comfortable with going to places like Union Carbide road, for instance, and displaying my shock at the appearance of someone's home by walking up and snapping photos. This has been a problem for me all over India. Everything around me the whole time I've been here has been incredible in a wide variety of ways. I've only felt comfortable with taking photos of a few things, though.
In general, foreigners attract a lot of attention here, even just walking outside. Except for my companions here at Sambhavna, I have not seen a single Westerner here in Bhopal or in Madhya Pradesh. I don't really expect to see any, either. I don't think anyone comes here to visit. So people really look at us. Adults just look, but the children speak right up as soon as they see me. Most commonly they say "hello!" or "hello! how are you?!" very enthusiastically and in an almost inquiring way, and they are very pleased if I bounce back with a "hello, I'm fine, thank you!" It's pretty much the only English they know and I think they just get a big kick out of using it and getting a response. The way children, and even some adults here in India look at me has been very intense. Not in a bad way. Very refreshing, actually, after so many years in 'let's-all-pretend-we-we're-not-standing-here-together-in-this-subway/elevator/cafe' New York. People here really look at you, right into your eyes. That morning I had breakfast with the hotel owner in Jaipur I kept looking down at my plate and to the side and every time I'd glance back up his eyes were locked into mine, gazing right to the very back of them. Looking at him felt like looking into the sun. I found that a lot here. It is a good thing.
At night it's just the three of us here along with a couple of guards that watch the entrance to the clinic. We sit outside on the terrace to eat or drink tea. There are many moments when I feel like we are on a space station together. Or maybe like we are at one of those Antarctic laboratory stations. Of course we are surrounded by people here, but it's quite an alien panorama, especially if you've just arrived. Also, there only a couple of people here who speak fluent English -- Sathyu and Rachna. There are then a few others who speak some English. And that's it. My Hindi is still way too limited to really talk with people. I'm working on it, though. Very soon I might be the only foreigner here, at least for a while. Matthias is leaving in two weeks and Maude might leave even before then. Sathyu and Rachna are great company, too, but they are extremely busy and don't do much hanging out upstairs. This very charismatic 13-year-old boy named Zuber who lives nearby has latched onto me and comes everyday and stands on the other side of the clinic's fence and calls out my name. He really wants to hang out and be friends, but I badly need to learn more Hindi.
I took this week's dose of mefloquine this morning and I'm feeling a little nauseated from it. I'm really glad, though, that I came here already on it instead of assuming there wouldn't be enough mosquitos in January to justify the side effects. There actually aren't that many mosquitos most of the time, but in the evening they are everywhere and very aggressive. Matthias got sick again last night with malarial symptoms and he is worried that the chloroquine & primaquine combo isn't working, but it is still too early to tell. I'm the only one around here taking mefloquine because people want to avoid the side effects. The malaria treatment involves taking up to six times the normal dosage of chloroquine, though, and the side effects from that aren't pleasant, either. And neither is the malaria, of course.
I did end up bringing my ipod to India, with the excuse that it contained three volumes of Hindi lessons on it. Hanna had told me last year that when she came to Bhopal she couldn't listen to any of the music she brought because it just made no sense over there. This hasn't been exactly the case for me. Hipsters and irony don't make any sense here. That makes dead weight out of roughly half my ipod. The album I've been listening to most is U2's *All That You Can't Leave Behind*. It's funny because I never listened to any U2 at all back in NYC -- it was always a little too wholesome for me back there. Here I like it a lot. The music is earnest and unpretentious to my ears, and throws frequent bones to the more serious problems of the world. Maybe I just don't know anything about Bono and that's fine, really. I don't want to know. It's a little life raft for me right now. I badly need some rock and roll, and with as little b.s. as possible.
There is almost constant music coming from the area surrounding the clinic. I arrived here halfway through a nearby wedding celebration that lasted for three days. They had a very loud sound system and played a loop of mostly Hindi songs until past midnight and starting back up at around sunrise. Non-stop. And a live hand drummer, too. Some of the music they played was Western and was quite surreally ill-fitted to our surroundings. When we walked over there, for instance, they cranked up this house beat song "Shake Your Booty." All the kids went wild jumping up and down ecstatically and freeze dancing into these fantastic poses. This in a place where there are almost as many goats and cows walking around as there are people. And I am 100% sure that no one around here knows what "shake your booty" means.
Then there is the Muslim prayer cantor, too. The one closest to here is a little off key, I think. I liked the one by my hotel in Jaipur, better, actually. I didn't hear any in Udaipur. There are also explosions all the time, sometimes one every 30 seconds, like right now as I type this. They are the same "fireworks" I heard in Udaipur. I have to put "fireworks" in quotes because they are just so totally bombs. They sound the way it sounds when a transformer on an electrical pole blows up. It's a deep, full-bodied boom that I can feel in my chest if it's not too far away.
Ok, I should stop now and try to get some sleep. Lots to do tomorrow. There is so much more to write about, but I'll have to save it for later. For now, though, I should say that I feel very good. It has been two weeks since I arrived in India. In those two weeks I have learned that I am not nearly as tough as I thought I was in a lot of ways, but I have also amazed myself -- watched myself, really, almost from above, with compassionate fascination. Coming to India and to Bhopal, especially, has been a very good thing for me. I haven't been so happy in a very long time. More later,
MM